A blog about the work lawyers do to win commercial disputes by Will Newman
Judges make many decisions during a lawsuit. They set schedules, decide what parties need to disclose in discovery, dismiss claims, and direct the entry of judgments. And while many courts do not specify the limits for what decisions may get reargued, in practice, parties often ask judges to reconsider certain important decisions.
Read MoreIn Poland there is an unusual division between attorneys-at-law (in Polish: “radcowie prawni”) and advocates (in Polish: “adwokaci”). Currently, both professions have identical competences, including representing clients before all the courts, a path to the professions is similar and it is easy to change the profession between them. The reasons of this division have mainly historical character. From the client's point of view, it does not matter whether he or she cooperates with an attorney-at-law or with an advocate.
Read MoreWhen a defendant moves to dismiss, she asks the court to dismiss the case (usually in its entirety, but sometimes just in part) generally for one of two reasons. The first reason is that the court cannot hear the claim, either because the defendant is not subject to jurisdiction in the court or because the claim belongs in a different kind of court. And the second reason is that the complaint does not contain the necessary allegations to support a claim.
Read MoreAlthough it is rare for a negligence plaintiff to win a case on summary judgment in litigation, it happens sometimes. It is rare because a defendant will often present some evidence that he acted reasonably. But when a defendant fails to present such an explanation, he may lose before trial.
Read MoreLabor cases are resolved fairly quickly, especially those involving layoffs. Normally the conciliation occurs within a month, and if there is no agreement between one and three months there is a trial.
Read MoreIn American lawsuits, litigants usually have to search all of their email accounts and all of the physical spaces over which they exercise control. That’s a lot! It could include homes, offices, computers, external hard drives, USB hard drives, cloud email accounts, cell phones, storage spaces, and more. And for corporate litigants, it could apply not just to one clearly relevant employee, but to a whole list of possibly relevant employees.
Read MoreMunicipalities, states, and the federal government pass laws that regulate certain conduct. And some of those laws state that an administrative agency is responsible for either investigating or hearing complaints about violations of those laws.
Read MoreAfter the final decision in an arbitration, the losing party has one last recourse: it can ask a court to vacate the arbitration award. But because arbitration is meant to be a substitute for litigation, and not to duplicate it, courts are very reluctant to grant that relief.
Read MoreBesides objecting on the grounds of the privilege, many courts have rules that limit the instances in which a lawyer can instruct a witness not to answer a question. The lawyer’s only recourse in those cases is to immediately end the deposition and make a motion in court for a protective order, preventing the questioning attorney from asking the question again in a future deposition.
Read MoreEach side at trial usually only has a finite amount of time. For example, a judge may allocate 20 hours to each side. As a result, a lawyer may decide that it makes sense to allow one side to waste some of its time on irrelevant evidence or to bury its good evidence in a mountain of dull evidence. Similarly, if one side believes it has a great rebuttal to opposing evidence and that rebuttal will improve its case, it may consent to the admission of opposing evidence so that it can dramatically present its rebuttal.
Read MoreIndividuals cannot file constitutional cases directly with The Constitutional Court of Romania. If constitutional matters are raised during commercial matters, the judge of the commercial matter may file a case with the constitutional court regarding the constitutional matters raised and it will be solved independently of the pending commercial matter.
Read MoreMany agreements are governed by the statute of frauds, a legal doctrine that requires certain agreements to be in writing. But a signed contract is not the only kind of agreement that satisfies this rule.
Read More
