More Thoughts on the Uniform Commercial Code
A major purpose of the Uniform Commercial Code (UCC) is to provide consistent guidance on commercial transactions. And so, this may not seem to be a subject whose blog post needs an update just a few years later. But the advent of AI in every part of the law, including commercial litigation, has made the UCC worth considering again. I share some new thoughts.
There is something counterintuitive about the UCC. It is meant to provide default rules that are true across jurisdictions so that people who do not draft agreements can have their reasonable needs met in court. At the same, the UCC is complex, which makes it challenging for even people who work with it every day to be clear on what it is requires. Experienced market players would likely sign agreements that substitute UCC rules for their own contract terms. Ultimately, people’s expectations in business are also complex, so an agreement should codify these issues in a way that people can act upon.
Many people now use AI to draft agreements and to ask basic legal questions. According to Thompson Reuters and other industry surveys, about half of legal professionals today use some generative AI to write contracts, and businesspeople are using AI at nearly the same rate to review them before signing.
AI can pick up on issues in which the UCC and other relevant commercial statutes apply, details that drafters may have missed in the past. As a result, people may be able to apply UCC principles more often now without actually citing the law or litigating it in court because those principles are baked into the advice and drafts that AI provides. Still, evaluating machine-generated texts requires the critical thinking that human expertise brings to the table.
The UCC adopted changes to account for cryptocurrency transactions. States are slowly passing those changes into law—such as New York’s 2026 adoption of changes from 2022—so these changes in the legal world often lag behind exploration of these new frontiers in commercial practice. National changes don’t happen every year, either. They tend to be made only every few years about specific subjects.
***
In the United States, most commercial transactions are governed by state contract law. But because many companies do business in multiple states, it was burdensome for companies to research contract law across 50 states. To address this issue, we developed the UCC. It is not a federal law, but a uniformly adopted state law. Every state has adopted substantially similar laws.
Why should you continue to read this post about the UCC?
Because you are a business person and you are interested in learning more about one law that governs your work.
Because you do not have time to read 50 different blog posts about contracts in each state.
Because this post is probably easier to read than the actual UCC.
Image credit:
Uniform Commercial Code 2007 ed., photographed at the Berkeley law school’s library in 2009 by Coolcaesar.
See English Wikipedia, CC BY-SA 3.0.
When does the UCC Apply?
The UCC becomes binding law that applies to transactions when a state has officially adopted the UCC. Since every U.S. state has adopted a version of the UCC, this usually means that the UCC applies to commercial transactions in every state. In one major exception, Louisiana has not directly adopted Article 2 of the UCC due to Louisiana’s unique legal history, so the UCC does not apply to commercial sales and leases under Louisiana law.
There are different articles of the UCC, and each concerns a different type of commercial transaction. For example, Article 2A concerns leases of goods (such as a hell-or-high-water clause), Article 8 concerns securities (such as stocks), and Article 9 concerns secured transactions (generally debts that have collateral).
But because the UCC terms itself are often very complex, it may be necessary to analyze the actual facts of a case to determine whether the UCC applies.
What does the UCC say?
The UCC is very long. As you can see in the picture above, it fills a thick book. But it provides a lot of rules about when, exactly, a contract officially exists between two parties and how to determine what the terms of their agreement are in the event of ambiguities. For example, the UCC allows parties to form an enforceable sales contract, even if they have not agreed on a price. It also allows parties to modify sales contracts, even if this modification only benefits one side of the agreement.
Many UCC rules are about what happens in the event of a breach. For example, it says that a seller is usually responsible for the quality of goods until they arrive at the buyer’s place, except in certain situations. And it lays out how a buyer can reject defective goods.
The UCC also governs how creditors can establish their entitlement to collateral in the event a debtor defaults on the loan. The process involves filing a standard form, a Financing Statement, in a state government office.
The UCC Does Not Always Govern Every Aspect of a Commercial Transaction
Even though the UCC provides rules for many aspects of commercial transactions, it does not always govern everything.
First, parties to a commercial transaction may vary the terms of their relationship through a contract. So, even if the UCC states that a seller is responsible for the quality of goods while they are in transit, two parties may agree in a contract to change that rule and transfer the risk to the buyer.
And second, some aspects of commercial transactions may require the application of other laws. For example, the UCC may govern secured transactions where personal property is the collateral, but different state laws may apply when real estate is the collateral. And for international sales transactions, other uniform laws, like the Convention on the Sale of International Goods, may apply. This is where the UCC meets the seven seas. Contract law, anywhere, requires legal know-how to navigate.